Skip to main navigation Skip to Content

IPM

  • Director's Message
  • About IPM
  • The Constitution of IPM
  • Contact US
  • فارسي
  • Home
  • People
    • Administrative Board
    • Founding Fellows of IPM
    • Scientific Council of IPM
    • Academic Staff
  • Schools
    • Astronomy
    • Biological Sciences
    • Cognitive Sciences
    • Computer Science
    • Mathematics
    • Nano Science
    • Particles and Accelerators
    • Philosophy
    • Physics
  • Centers and Units
    • Brain Engineering Laboratory
    • Condensed Matter National Laboratory
    • Grid Computing Group
    • Iranian Light Source Facility
    • Iranian National Observatory
    • IRNIC
    • Library
    • Network Center
  • Publications
    • Akhbar
    • Papers
    • Books
    • Annual Report
  • Bulletin Board
  • Calendar
  • E - Catalog















Home
  • “ Schools ”

    IPM
    • Astronomy
    • Cognitive Sciences
    • Computer Science
    • Mathematics
    • Nano Science
    • Particles and Accelerators
    • Philosophy
    • Physics

    “ Centers and Units ”

    IPM
    • GCG Computing Group
    • Information Center
    • Iranian Light Source Facility
    • Iranian National Observatory
    • IRNIC
    • Library
    • Network Center

    “ Research Groups ”

    IPM
    • Bioinformatics
    • Combinatorics and Computing
    • Commutative Algebra
    • Logic
    • IPM HPC Laboratory

    “ Useful Links ”

    IPM
    • Gallery of Visitors
    • Contact Us
    • Gallery of Photos

    “ E-Services ”

    IPM
    • Webmail
    • Official Automation System
    • Library
    • Telephone Book
  • “School of Philosophy”

     
    Paper   IPM / Philosophy / 11599
       School of Analytic Philosophy
      Title: Deontic vs. Nondeontic Conceptions of Epistemic Justification
      Author(s): H. Vahid
      Status: Published
      Journal: Erkenntnis
      Vol.: 49
      Year: 1998
      Pages: 285-301
      Supported by:           IPM IPM
      Abstract:
    Theories of epistemic justification are usually described as belonging to either deontological or nondeontological categories of justification with the former construing the concept of justification as involving the fulfillment of epistemic duty. Despite being the dominant view among traditional epistemologists, the deontological conception has been subjected to severe criticisms in the current literature for failing, among others, to do justice to the (alleged) truth-conducive character of epistemic justification. In this paper I set out to show that there is something deeply unsatisfying about the way these different conceptions of justification are usually introduced and contrasted with each other leaving it unclear just what it is that renders a particular conception deontological. In particular I look at Alston's treatment of the issue, and show that his reasons for rejecting the deontological conception involve question-begging assumptions demonstrating, at best, the possibility of its divergence from truth-conductive justification. Far from being able to settle the issue one way or another, the arguments, I shall suggest actually seem to show some sort of tolerant pluralism in justification theory to be a live option.

    Download TeX format
    back to top
footer
  • -IPM
  • -20 Years
  • -INO
  • -ILSF
  • -GCG
  • -Iranet
  • -LIBRARY
  • -NIC
  • -BIO
  • -CCG
  • -Logic
prev next

Exploring IPM

  • People
    • Administrative Board
    • Senior Fellows of IPM
    • Scientific Council of IPM
    • Academic Staff
  • Schools
    • Astronomy
    • Biolgical Sciences
    • Cognitive Sciences
    • Computer Science
    • Mathematics
    • Nano Science
    • Particles and Accelerators
    • Philosophy
    • Physics
  • Centers
    • Brain Engineering Center
    • Condensed Matter National Laboratory
    • Deputy for Research
    • Grid Computing Group
    • Information Center
    • Iranian Light Source Facility
    • Iranian National Observatory
    • IRNIC
    • Library
    • Network Center
  • Groups
    • Bioinformatics
    • Combinatorics and Computing
    • Logic
    • Commutative Algebra
    • IPM HPC Laboratory
  • E-Services
    • Library Catalog
    • Official Automation System
    • Official Automation System (dabir)
    • Telephone Book
    • Webmail
  • Publications
    • Akhbar
    • Papers
    • Books

 COPYRIGHT 2012 © ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

Please submit your comments or questions here, or contact Webmaster  |  ipmic@ipm.ir